September 18, 2009

Madden NFL 10 | Final Review

Jimmy James 70 Says Blood and sweat. Pain and broken bones. The men who play football aren’t playing around. I’ll leave it to the 300-lb linebackers and the 7-foot tall quarterbacks to risk it all on the grid iron. For me, I prefer my overstuffed chair, a cold drink, and a bowl of chips. I give new meaning to the term ‘armchair quarterback,’ and I’m proud to say I took the Raiders to the Super Bowl and won, even though I had to restart the game three times. Who knew Barber could run the ball so well? That’s right, only in Madden NFL 10 would you see a headline such as, “Raiders Defeat Cowboys in Super Bowl XLIV.” The Raiders and Cowboys haven’t been Super Bowl contenders in years, or maybe even decades, and yet in Madden it’s all possible.

I took a lowly team like the Raiders and a QB like Russell, and turned them into champions. The ratings for my star players shot up like a rocket after that first season. Asomugha is now rated at a 99, Russell is into the 70’s, and McFadden broke into the 80’s. They still have a ways to go to be considered a Manning or a Tomlinson, but that’s the beauty of video game football: I can take them to the highest highs.

Franchise mode, at least for me, is really the way to go. Yes, I did play several matches on Xbox Live, and I also lost several matches on Xbox Live. It was a little disheartening to know I suck so incredibly bad. But after a few games at My Skill level and pummeling the Steelers with no problem, my confidence levels went right back up. I do have to say though, EA is doing an excellent job with the online games. I experienced no lag, no dropped games, and thankfully, my opponents kept their mouths shut and I never ran across the typical homophobic racist who’s become all too common in online matches.

Then there’s the age-old question of, “Do we really need another Madden?” And the answer my friend, is Yes, we do need another Madden. Every year. Every August. Another Madden. Why? Because the game keeps getting better and better. The graphics are getting better and better. The controls are getting better and better. The announcers are getting…well, they’re the same, but Collinsworth has grown on me and I actually like him on Sunday Night Football. No one will replace Madden, but Collinsworth is worthy (and he puts to shame those MNF guys).

The chances are very likely that I’ll be here in August and September of 2010, discussing Madden NFL 11. And once again I’ll be saying, this game rocks. It’s adrenaline pumping, it’s ego-boosting, and it’s addictive like all good games are; so now I ask you, “Are you ready for some FOOTBALL?”

Digg!

September 17, 2009

WET | First Impressions

Shawn Lebert says … Fasten your seatbelts, or perhaps unfasten them, you daredevil you, as you partake on an over-the-top, no holds barred, thrill ride with Rubi Malone, who loves bullets and a body count. With its pure grindhouse-ish façade, Ms. Malone’s best friends are an arsenal of whatever kills you, plus a katana. The exaggeration of blood and death is mighty vibrant as you play through the game, and there’s a strong faded film appearance overtop the game play – which points to nothing less than the exploitive media from decades ago.

WET is a stylish, acrobatic shooter that puts you in control of Rubi, who also happens to be the master of acrobatics: jumping through the air, running across walls and sliding against any flooring with guns a-blazing. If anything, it’ll quickly remind of you past, inspired “gunfu” games, like Stranglehold from this game generation. Although without a plethora of gunning options like Stranglehold, there seems to be only a limited number of possible stylish movements in WET, which might sound as a disappointment; however, there might be more fleshed-out acrobatic movements as you progress further into the game.
The game provides some eye-catching voice talent, from actors like Eliza Dushku and Alan Cumming, which has been solid so far and may bring in more of an audience due to some familiar faces on the big screen.

Rubi can be controlled in various ways, in third person, when assaulting the ones who get in her way. The game stresses to use more acrobatics than just a standard of running and gunning. Mostly prominent is the combo meter, which is chaining kill attacks through snazzy, seamless ways without looking boring. And in doing so, gives you the forever slick slow-mo gun down in all moments of the game to escape dangerous gunfire or events. For button mashing enthusiasts, WET shows off some button prompts here and there in events that need much more detail in cut-scenes than actual game play. An event on a freeway is reminiscent of big epic battle scenes like Matrix Reloaded, as Rubi stands atop vehicles, firing at her foes at 70MPH, but also hopping and diving on to the hoods of other vehicles.

A different feature, is the Rage mode. When Rubi is pissed off, the areas are colored in red, white, and black, which gives off a cool appearance in a three-dimensional environment. You don’t want to get her panties in a bunch, or she’ll go Rage on you and leave you in the dust. This mode is heavy on chain-kills; it seems like a means to see just how far you can build up the chain kill effect for your own personal gain to brag about it. Hopefully, there is much more involvement with the Rage effect and that it’s not just a tacked-on feature.

The graphics are a bit mediocre for this third-person shooter. In fact, they might have taken a step back into the past, as it doesn’t seem to impress and is perhaps the game’s weakest point. It might remind you of a Western called GUN from a few years back, and the fact that it compares to a game that far back, makes it disappointing.

A few hours into the game and WET seems like a game guilty of endless violence for the sweet tooth and obliterating the opponents in numerous ways makes it amusing.
Stay tuned for the full review to see just how entertaining this game is.

Special Editor's Note: This is your opportunity to win 5 Goozex tokens. Simply be the first person to leave a comment and let us know why you are or are not looking forward to playing WET. Also, leave your Goozex User Name so I know who to give the tokens to. If you're not a member of Goozex, and you want to join for free (and get one token in the process), then click here.

Digg!

September 16, 2009

Interview with Richard Ham, Creative Director at Splash Damage (Brink)

Dale Culp says: Last week, I wrote up a preview of Brink based on a demo seen at PAX. Immediately following the demo, I caught up with the Creative Director at Splash Damage Studios, Richard Ham, for a deeper look into the world of Brink.

Dale: So, how long has this game been in development?

RH: Um, they started it about a year, year and a half ago. I came on, actually, about a year ago, started basically at the beginning of 2008.

Dale: So, this is pretty close to done?

RH: Oh, actually, I'd say we've got a ways to go. We're about to go Alpha within the next month or so. Actually, this version you saw is several months old. This our E3 demo we put together and we have just been using it here because so many people didn't see it.

Dale: I noticed some of the animations seemed a bit rough. A few of the guys didn't even react to being shot, they just sort of fell to the ground after they died.

RH: Ah! The joys of ragdoll.

Dale: I did see a couple of guys who reacted to a grenade, though. I actually saw his knees bend forward as his body wrenched backward – that's the kind of stuff I like to see. I love the context, when the enemies react to being shot.

RH: Exactly, yeah. Ragdolls are really, really hard. We actually have a guy who's working full-time on it. It's odd; our expectations of what somebody looks like when they die are completely wrong. Based on movies where an actor tries to pretend he's dead, he doesn't truly go dead. You know? He still has tension in his muscles and whatnot because he's really alive. When you see somebody really die it looks really weird and wrong because they do just completely drop dead. But we do have to actually take this physical simulation and limit it such that it looks more like an actor dying, which is an odd thing.

Dale: Right, right. We've all seen that episode of MythBusters where they shot the dummy and it barely moved.

RH: Exactly! Yeah.

Dale: People don't just go flying off into the air after they've been shot.

RH: [laughs]

Dale: So, let's talk about the story of Brink; what is Ark?

RH: Basically, Ark was built right around now – between 2005 and 2010 – as kind of a prototype for what mankind's perfect, dream future could be. You know, with zero carbon emissions, renewable energy, renewable food supply – all the stuff that has been kind of a pipe dream of what we need to do for humanity, they actually proved it. We've done a lot of our research for the background of our game and based it off stuff that's really existing today. We had one bit of science-fiction in our game which was they created this new building material which was basically a replacement for concrete, because concrete, when it sets, gives off lots of CO2 gasses which is a huge problem. So, we created a science-fiction version of concrete. Turns out, I read on Slashdot about a month ago, they've actually really created it now. So, it's really grounded in the now.

Anyway, so, they've built this city that houses about 5,000 people. It was like the 8th Wonder of the World. I mean, the technology was fantastic and was going to really change mankind's future. Everything was gonna be great, but then, the inconvenient truth happens.

Dale: Where is Ark supposed to be?

RH: It's out at sea, kind of in the doldrums, near the Equator. They actually towed it out there from San Francisco Bay because that's where they'd have the least impact from wave distortions and whatnot. So, they got it out there, it had a working airport so they could bring people out there. They were pursuing the technologies and trying to get out there, but then the worldwide flooding did happen and it displaced hundreds of millions of people. A lot of them, as refugees, came to the Ark because, of course, the Ark was fine -- it floats -- and the Ark didn't turn anybody away. It was like their biggest mistake because they were all about helping mankind, so they brought in as many people as they could.

Now, the game begins about 30 years after that. There's been enough time for a whole generation to grow up in the Ark, and while it was originally supposed to house around 5,000 people, it now houses around 50,000. They've lost contact with the outside world – they know it's out there, but they just really haven't heard form them for like 15 years or so. They know it's rough so they kinda keep to themselves, but things are really bad on the Ark as well. The resources are running out, all this technology that was so great is breaking down and they don't have the means to fix it, and tensions are on the edge as the resources are getting, you know, scarcer and scarcer. So, at the beginning of the game, the whole place is on the... BRINK [Richard pauses and smiles while pointing to a large display showing off the game] of a civil war – and that's where you come in, as the civil war starts. The storyline in the game actually covers the first week of that civil war.

Dale: So, I'm hearing this story about a city at sea, broken off and independent from the rest of the world with high ideals and hopes for the future until something really bad happens, and I can't help but start thinking Rapture and Bioshock, but as I learn more I start seeing how this is actually very different.

RH: Well, I mean, I can't speak for those guys, Ken Levine and all that... I don't know where they took their inspiration from, but in a lot of ways I think it is kind of a big, cosmic coincidence. This is a storyline that Paul has wanted to do for almost 10 years now. You know, when he founded the company, this was a really big thing, he wanted this notion of a floating city. You know, this is finally our chance to do it because Bethesda are actually allowing us to do original IP as opposed to another Quake or Wolfenstein game. So, I think there's a lot of overlap, but we are really unique and I think probably the biggest thing about us is that we're not that much of a flight of fancy. There are things like the Ark being built in the world today.

Dale: I remember a news story about a guy building an island out of recycled bottles.

RH: [laughs] Exactly! Yeah, I mean, there's this place called the Seasteading Institute - http://seasteading.org/ - and if you go to their website, they actually have instructions for how to create the Ark. So, we did take a lot of inspiration from the real world. Now, I hope... Obviously, we're creating a kick-ass shooter, first of all, that's going to be a lot of fun to play, but there are actually a lot of things that really do harken to what's going on in the real world, and for the players who are interested and want to delve into the backstory of the game, I think there's a lot for them to discover.

Dale: I want to ask about the multiplayer aspect. Will your friends really be able to jump in and out as you're playing the game?

RH: Yeah. I'll be honest, we took a lot of inspiration from Left 4 Dead. I think Left 4 Dead is a fantastic game that really pushed a lot of boundaries and made things that were previously unacceptable acceptable, like the notion that, it's ok that if you and I are playing the game and you have to go to the bathroom, you can go idle and a bot will take over for you and you can come back in a few minutes.

Dale: That leads into my next question where I noticed that, during the demo, when he [the guy giving the demo] when into a menu, the action was still happening. Are you then vulnerable, at that point?

RH: YES! You are vulnerable, which is actually why we've gone with the radial menu motif, because it can be as fast as you can move your thumb. It's not like going through a bunch of nested lists... Every time you go to one of the command posts, you kind of have an idea, already, of what you want to do. You know you want to switch to an engineer. Engineer is always the choice that's on the left. So, you go up there, hit LEFT... Boom – you're done. You know, so, the radial menu can be fantastic because you can develop a muscle memory where you just know where the things are and you can just do them.

Dale: Does switching classes cost you anything?

RH: No. In fact, you gain experience points. Let's say your team needs an engineer, so your prize is a certain number of experience points to get you become what your team needs you to be.

Dale: What do you get for experience points?

RH: Well, basically, we have a leveling system that is more akin to what you get in an MMO. There are 4 classes in the game – soldier, medic, operative and engineer – and each one of those classes has a big number of individual abilities. You start with just a couple of them but there's a ton to unlock. There's also a ton of abilities which you can have at any time – no matter what class you are. As you level up, there's lots of things to buy and it's really up to you to decide to build a character that makes you unique and really reflects how you want to play. Another thing is, if you buy a particular ability and you decide you don't like it, you can sell it back. So, you aren't ever trapped in any particular kind of ability.

Dale: At first blush, Brink looks really complicated. I mean, I was like, “Wow, there's a lot going on...”

RH: Yeah.

Dale: And then it started clicking that everything you do is a quest... and it actually almost looked like you were playing an MMO but single-player.

RH: Oh, yeah, in action. Yeah.

Dale: So, then the AI constantly generates things for you to do, based on what you've been doing?

RH: Yeah, there's this concept of an AI that's basically watching over your entire team, paying attention to strength and weaknesses and what's going on...

Dale: Kind of like the director in Left 4 Dead?

RH: Yeah, very much like the cinematic director from Left 4 Dead. The important thing is that, even though there's a ton of stuff going on, if you're fresh and new to the game, one of the first things we'll teach you when you first start playing is, hey, when you look at the wheel, the thing at the top is the one we recommend. All the other ones you can look at if you want so you still make the decisions, but if you do the one at the top, you'll be helping everyone out. So, if you don't want to think about it, just choose that. In fact, if you really don't want to think about it, if you want to be quick, instead of holding the button to bring up the wheel, you can just tap that button and it will automatically assign that goal to you. The arrow will come up and tell you where to go so you'll never get lost.

Dale: And you can give your AI teammates different orders, and they'll follow them?

RH: Exactly. That's a really interesting thing... We're a multiplayer game, but by default, we turn off voice chat.

Dale: Wait, you turn OFF voice chat?

RH: Right, because in multiplayer, as often as it can be a really big boon to teamplay and all that, 9 times out of 10 it's really all about somebody calling you... well, I won't repeat it because you're recording me.

Dale: Ah, ok. Yeah, lots of dirty mouths on Xbox Live.

RH: [laughing] Right. So, in taking that off, you can turn it on, and you know, listen to your friends speak, but I just don't want to take the chance of you having some 12-year-old, homophobic racist...

Dale: You don't want them ruining your game experience while you're trying to get everyone to do their job.

RH: Exactly! But, we don't want to give up on that notion of communication that voice gives you, so when you choose an objective off that wheel, the game automatically – in your character's voice, because you can define what your character's voice is – messages the rest of the team, “I'm on my way to become an engineer!” Everybody else hears that and thinks, “Oh, good! Somebody's going to be an engineer. I don't have to worry about that, anymore.” And, in fact, because you've just gone off and made yourself an engineer, you've basically become the MVP of your team. You are the most important guy because you're the only one who can fix that crane, so the other guys will get new objectives, very high-priority objectives to keep that engineer alive. So, the fact that you've done something is creating new missions for other players – and that's happening all the time, live and dynamically. And, if you want, you can pay attention to everything that's going on and make all the high-level decisions, or, if you're like, “I don't know what to do!” just tap UP and it's like a buddy on your couch who knows the game really well, saying, “You should go change into an engineer.” That's what the wheel represents, it's the game helping you out.

Dale: Very cool. I noticed, also, that the AI seems really smart. I noticed during the demo, he went around the back and a guy was just standing there until the player reloaded, or cocked his gun, and the AI heard that and turned right around to investigate the noise. Obviously, the AI is smart enough to keep track of everything else, but it seems like it can give you quite a challenge one-on-one.

RH: Oh, yeah, definitely. The big advantage we have is this is being done with iD Tech 4 – not 5 – which is the same engine we used for Quake Wars. Now, Quake Wars had fantastic bots. Really, really smart, they were able to do some complicated things. Really smart about driving, providing backup for each other... They really went above and beyond; we've got that as our base. We can build on that and keep on putting more and more stuff in, so that's actually been a really big boon. So, because our goal is to ensure that, you know, it doesn't matter if you're playing online or offline, you get that same experience. So, our bots, pretty much, have to be capable of doing everything a human can do. Their AI tree is actually based off that same wheel. At any given time, they've got the same wheel that a player would have and they're making choices the same way a player would.

Dale: I like that this looks very unique, it's not just another bunch of space marines, or like, helmet-guy with a gun. I also noticed that, and I want to be very careful about saying this, but the characters look... French.

RH: [laughs] Ok, you do know that our art director is Olivier Leonardi? He is French...

Dale: Oh, actually, I didn't know that. I mean, they even have kind of an accent, and to be honest, I'm not trying to play on stereotypes, but they kind of look like Jean Reno. You know? He has a very distinctive look.

RH: [laughs more] Yeah, it was actually a choice that was made very early on to not go photorealistic. In fact, that's something that Olivier, the art director, he pushed back, because we were all a little bit nervous about it... we thought, well, are players going to actually accept this? The safe thing is to do photreal and look like everything else out there, but in the end, he was right, because ever since E3, there have been some people who are saying, “What's with the tiny heads?” But by and large, the vast majority of people are, you know, they recognize it's something new and are excited about it. I don't think we gave players enough credit at first. We kind of pigeon-holed them into, “Yeah, they'll just want the same old, same old,” but people are really excited about seeing something different, which is great.

Dale: I definitely agree; I mean, even the colors are very unique.

RH: Oh, yeah. Yes. That's actually a real important thing. Like that level you just saw [which featured a waterfront dock setting with plenty of metal crates and junk piles] would be very, very easy to do it all in just various shades of rust, but we decided to have big splashes of blue and red.

Dale: It definitely stands out, I'm very impressed. So, the game is due out Spring 2010?

RH: Yeah, knock on wood.

Dale: Very cool, thank you very much!


Special thanks to Richard Ham and the rest of the folks at Splash Damage/Bethesda for allowing me access to do this interview.
Brink will be available for PC, PS3 and Xbox 360.

Digg!

September 14, 2009

Future Releases Worth Your Purchase

Cole Burton Says As all of us gamers know, there are very many great and popular games coming out this year and the next. That is why I am going to give my opinions on some of the games that I am most hyped for.

Call of Duty: Modern
Warfare 2
I used to be a huge Halo fan, but after 5 minutes of Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare, all that changed. There are 3 editions of Modern Warfare 2: Normal, Hardened, and Prestige edition. I currently have the prestige edition pre-ordered for $150.00, that’s how much I like Call of Duty.

This game will have a great campaign and multiplayer by the looks of it. Not only that, it will also have the new, two-player special ops missions.

In addition, there are many improvements, such as in-game host finding and the ability to throw your knife.

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
Uncharted 2 is a game that I plan on getting from The New Goozex Exchange day 1. I loved Uncharted: Drakes Fortune and I was lucky enough to get a beta code from GameTrailers to play the first level cooperatively and play the multiplayer, I was blown away.

There is so much suspense for this game just from the trailers alone. This is my second-most hyped game for the year, right behind Modern Warfare 2. For those of you looking to push your luck, there will be a limited, and I do mean limited, edition of the game. The only way to get it, will be to win it. Check the Playstation blog for more info.

Saw: The Video Game
In my opinion, Saw the video game hasn’t been getting enough attention. If you have seen the movies, this is a must get, if you haven’t seen the movies, watch the first two and you will be hooked. The game places you in the position of Detective Tapp from Saw 1 and it fills the gap between the first and second movies. Another cool thing about this Saw entry is that it will be produced by the original creators of Saw.

M.A.G.
M.A.G. might be one of the best PS3 exclusives of the year. It looks like it will have a great multiplayer with 256 players per match. Some people are worried about lag issues, but this game wouldn’t be made if that were a fact. No one would play a 256-man lag match. There are three teams you can choose from, at least one should fit your fps personality.

Halo ODST
Although I do not play Halo that much anymore, I still plan on getting ODST for old-time sake and to complete my collection.

Assassin’s Creed 2
I enjoyed Assassin’s Creed a lot until I finished the game, then it had right next to zero replay value. However, I am sure the sequel will not have this problem, but, if it does, at least the first play through will be great.
This time, you don’t play as Altair, you play as Ezio. There will also be more weapons and vehicles. In addition, you will have friends that have their own abilities to help you out.

Battlefield: Bad Company 2
I played the demo of BF:BC and did not like it. I eventually got it on goozex with some spare points and was amazed. Apparently, the demo sucked but the real game was great!
In addition, the multiplayer was great. I cannot wait to add this game to my collection March 2010. The destructible environments were what separated bad company from other mindless fps games and it look like it will do the same again.
I hope you guys enjoyed reading about some of the games I am most hyped for this year and next. Remember to keep that wallet fat for these, or do the smart thing and get them from Goozex.com!

Digg!

360 vs PS3 - Which Offers the Better Games?

Troy Benedict Says Welcome to part 3 of the pound-per-pound comparison of the Xbox 360 and the PlayStation 3. In the first part of the series, I compared each system's online experience. In the second part, the home theater aspects of each machine were discussed. For this article, I will compare both console's game library, and determine which system offers the best games. What constitutes a good game or a bad game is very subjective, so for this comparison I went to Metacritic's web site and took a snapshot on September 4, 2009 of the entire list of review scores for each system's available games. The results were broken down into three categories:

  1. Multiplatform Titles - games that have been released for both consoles.
  2. Exclusive Titles - games that are available only on one console. They are exclusive, whether it a current timed-exclusive or an indefinite exclusivity. These can include disc-based releases or downloadable games (PlayStation Network or Xbox Live Arcade titles, for example).
  3. Total Games Library - this is a combination of exclusive and multiplatform games released for both consoles.

Within each category, you will see two tables of information:

  1. The first table breaks down the totals and averages for that category based on the titles' review score ranges. For example, you can see the average review score for games that scored between an 80 and 89 rating, the number of games that were rated within that 80-90 point range, and the percentage of titles that averaged between an 80-89 score compared to the other score ranges of that particular category (multiplatform, exclusive, or total library).

  2. The second table breaks down the review scores, for each category, based on the year that game was released, and the average review score.

Each category will also have the overall averages for each system, as well as the list of top-rated games per console. For the multiplatform and exclusive releases I have included each console's lowest-rated game -- just for fun!

Multiplatform Titles:
Multiplatform games are available on both the Xbox 360 or the PlayStation 3.

Of the 263 games available on both systems, the Xbox 360 average score is .7 points higher than the PlayStation 3's.

Average Review Score (Out of 100) For Multiplatform Titles

  • Xbox 360: 71.1
  • PlayStation 3: 70.4



Highest-Rated Multiplatform Games:

Xbox 360:

  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) - Average Score:98

PlayStation3:

  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) - Average Score:98

Best Xbox 360 Multiplatform Games (Average Score 90 or greater):

  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) Average Score: 98
  • BioShock (2008) Average Score: 96
  • Orange Box, The (2007) Average Score: 96
  • Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, The (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Street Fighter IV (2009) Average Score: 93
  • Fallout 3 (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Rock Band (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Rock Band 2 (2008) Average Score: 92
  • Batman: Arkham Asylum (2009) Average Score: 92

Best PlayStation 3 Multiplatform Games (Average Score 90 or greater):

  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) Average Score: 98
  • BioShock (2008) Average Score: 94
  • Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Street Fighter IV (2009) Average Score: 94
  • Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, The (2007) Average Score: 93
  • Rock Band (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Rock Band 2 (2008) Average Score: 91
  • Fallout 3 (2008) Average Score: 90
  • Batman: Arkham Asylum (2009) Average Score: 90
  • Guitar Hero 5 (2009) Average Score: 90

Lowest-Rated Multiplatform Games

Xbox 360:

  • Leisure Suit Larry: Box Office Bust (2009) - Average Score: 25

PlayStation3:

  • Leisure Suit Larry: Box Office Bust (2009) - Average Score: 18

There has been a long-standing debate about whether or not the Xbox 360 offers a better version releases.

The stats do not lie. The averages of all multiplatform releases do favor the Xbox 360. However, the differences are so insignificant with less than a 1 point difference.

Both systems have the same highest and lowest scoring games, GTA4 and Leisure Suit Larry: Box Office Bust, respectively.

The review scores were very similar. 90% of the games varied by a 4-point, or less, difference in review scores.Of the 263 compared multiplatform games:

  • 45 games received the same average review score.
  • 89 games received a 1-point difference average review scores.
  • 48 games received a 2-point difference average review scores.
  • 31 games received a 3-point difference average review scores.
  • 23 games received a 4-point difference average review scores.
  • 27 games received a 5-point or greater difference in the average review scores.
  • F.E.A.R. was the game with the biggest discrepancy, a 13-point difference. The game was released in 2006 for the Xbox 360 and received an average score of 85. It was released on the PlayStation 3 in 2007 and received an average score of 72.
  • 133 games were reviewed higher on the Xbox 360 by an average of 2.7 points.
  • 85 games were reviewed higher on the PlayStation 3 by an average of 2.1 points.

Xbox 360 enthusiasts may be pleased to know that their system edges out the competition with a VERY slight edge, and they have more higher-reviewed games, but here is an interesting fact. The 360 had the better multiplatform games in 2006, 2007, and 2008, but the PlayStation 3 is offering is dominating this year's multiplatform releases.Verdict
The numbers don't lie. Even if it's a slight advantage, the Xbox 360 offers the better multiplatform experience over the PlayStation 3. However, if the trend continues in the table above, the PlayStation 3 may very well offer the better experience for 2009's releases.

Exclusive Titles

Average Review Score (Out of 100) For System Exclusive Title:

  • Xbox 360: 66.4 (433 games)
  • PlayStation 3: 72.0 (127 games)


Highest-Rated Exclusive Game(s)
Xbox 360:

  • Gears of War (2006) - Average Score: 94
  • Halo 3 (2007) - Average Score: 94

PlayStation3:

  • LittleBigPlanet (2008) - Average Score:95

Best Xbox 360 Exclusive Games (Average Score 90 or greater):

  • Gears of War (2006) Average Score: 94
  • Halo 3 (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Braid (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Gears of War 2 (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Guitar Hero II (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Mass Effect (2007) Average Score: 91
  • Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter (2006) Average Score: 90
  • Grand Theft Auto IV: The Lost and Damned (2009) Average Score: 90
  • Portal: Still Alive (2008) Average Score: 90
  • Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved 2 (2008) Average Score: 90
  • Forza Motorsport 2 (2007) Average Score: 90

Best PlayStation 3 Exclusive Games (Average Score of 90 or greater):

  • LittleBigPlanet (2008) Average Score: 95
  • Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots (2008) Average Score: 94
  • Killzone 2 (2009) Average Score: 91
  • MLB 09: The Show (2009) Average Score: 90

Lowest-Rated Exclusive Game(s)
Xbox 360:

  • Yaris (2007) - Average Score: 17
PlayStation 3:
  • Vampire Rain: Altered Species (2008) - Average Score: 30
    Note: Vampire Rain is also available on Xbox 360, but this version features content not included in the 360 release, hence making it an exclusive title.
It might be shocking to see such a stark difference between the exclusive 360 releases and those on the PlayStation 3. The PlayStation is leading the march with a 72 point average versus the Xbox's 66.4. That quite a significant lead!


There is a reason for the 360's lower averages: the Xbox Live Arcade releases. The Xbox 360 offers a significantly larger number exclusive titles, more than 3 times what can only be purchased for a PlayStation, but a majority of those releases are less-than-stellar Xbox Live Arcade games. As you can see from the details above, Xbox 360's lowest-rated exclusive was, in fact, the free Xbox Live Arcade title Yaris.

Year to year, the Xbox 360 has offered more exclusives, almost 4 times as many in 2007, than the PlayStation 3. The Xbox 360 also has a significantly larger number of top-rated exclusive games, with 11 titles compared to PlayStation 3's 4 games.


Verdict
To be truly honest, the real answer to who wins the exclusive games category can't be made by dissecting review scores. The idea behind exclusivity is to offer something that the other guy doesn't have, in order to generate interest in your product over the competition's. Exclusives all come down to preference, and each system offers experiences that can't be made on the other system.

Based on numbers alone, the PlayStation 3 has a much higher average review score for it's exclusive titles. That being said, the PS3 also offers less than one-third of the exclusive games found on the 360.


Is it better to have a larger number of games to choose from -- with a guaranteed Xbox 360 Arcade release (or two, or three) each week? Or do you go with less variety and a slightly higher quality?

In situations like these, it makes me glad to own both systems.


Total Games Library (All Releases)

Average Review Score (Out of 100) For All Releases:
  • Xbox 360: 68.2 (696 games)
  • PlayStation 3: 70.9 (390 games)
Best of the Xbox 360 (Average Score 90 or greater):
  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) Average Score: 98
  • BioShock (2007) Average Score: 96
  • Orange Box, The (2007) Average Score: 96
  • Gears of War (2006) Average Score: 94
  • Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, The (2006) Average Score: 94
  • Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Halo 3 (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Braid (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Street Fighter IV (2009) Average Score: 93
  • Fallout 3 (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Gears of War 2 (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Guitar Hero II (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Rock Band (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Batman: Arkham Asylum (2009) Average Score: 92
  • Rock Band 2 (2008) Average Score: 92
  • Mass Effect (2007) Average Score: 91
  • Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter (2006) Average Score: 90
  • Grand Theft Auto IV: The Lost and Damned (2009) Average Score: 90
  • Portal: Still Alive (2008) Average Score: 90
  • Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved 2 (2008) Average Score: 90
  • Forza Motorsport 2 (2007) Average Score: 90

Best of the PlayStation 3 (Average Score 90 or greater):

  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) Average Score: 98
  • LittleBigPlanet (2008) Average Score: 95
  • Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (2007) Average Score: 94
  • BioShock (2008) Average Score: 94
  • Street Fighter IV (2009) Average Score: 94
  • Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots (2008) Average Score: 94
  • Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, The (2007) Average Score: 93
  • Rock Band (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Rock Band 2 (2008) Average Score: 91
  • Killzone 2 (2009) Average Score: 91
  • Batman: Arkham Asylum (2009) Average Score: 90
  • Fallout 3 (2008) Average Score: 90
  • MLB 09: The Show (2009) Average Score: 90
  • Guitar Hero 5 (2009) Average Score: 90
Verdict
The Total Games Library is a combination of both the exclusives and multiplatform games.


Numbers don't lie, but they don't always tell the whole truth, either. The numbers say that the PlayStation 3 offers the better overall experience. The trend in multiplatform games in 2009 seems to favor the PlayStation 3 as of early September. Does the fact that the 360 has 21 games with an average score of 90 or greater, compared to PS3's 14, make any difference? Or that the 360 offers the larger number of exclusives games by more than 300 titles? Or that the 360 had a year's head-start?

I'm going to leave it up to you, dear reader, to decide the final answer on this one. I, like the lawyer, present to you, the judge and jury, the facts.


Next up, the final comparison: each system's unique hardware offerings.

Digg!

JimmyJames70