Showing posts with label Xbox 360. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Xbox 360. Show all posts

January 25, 2010

Microsoft is bringing the arcade back with game room

Jason Trent says Microsoft recently announced their plans to launch the Xbox Game Room in an attempt to bring a classic arcade coin-op arcade experience to the masses of gamers using Xbox Live and Games for Windows live services. For those not in the know, the Xbox Game Room is a new application for use on both the Xbox 360 and Windows-based PCs where you and friends will have the ability to take your avatars through your custom created arcades. Here, you can challenge friends for an all-out battle to prove once and for all who the best gamer is. The idea is interesting, but I feel some of the particulars are flawed. What is it going to take for this to succeed as a new way to deliver retro titles to the end user?

The first thing people want to know is how much it will cost to enjoy their old favorites in the comfort of their new virtual play room. The game room itself is free, but the virtual arcade cabinets are not, so unless you want to be lounging in an empty room, you'll need to invest a little bit. The most appealing option is to purchase a title for use on one platform. For a mere 240 Microsoft Points (3 real people dollars), gamers will have unlimited play on an arcade title on either Xbox 360 or a Windows-based PC. If you want the freedom to experience your game on both platforms, you'll need to pony up 400 points (5 real people dollars). Finally, if you just want to try a game, you get one play free with additional plays costing 40 points a pop (2 real life quarters).

I can understand the 240 point price for unlimited plays of an arcade title, but 400 points to play on both my Xbox 360 and PC? That's crazy. Microsoft should be convincing me that I want to give them my money. Letting one Gamertag access the same game at two places shouldn't cost me almost double the price of a title. Further, who is going to spend 50 cents for one play on a game that is designed to eat quarters? We live in an age of nickle arcades. With 1000's of titles planned for release, you need to give me a much better price on a single play. Something more in the neighborhood of 10 cents (8 points) per play would get my attention.

Most of these games are already available for free play on the Internet, so their success is really going to be made or broken in the additional features offered. Things like leader boards and achievements are definitely a step in the right direction, but if they really want to capture the feeling of an arcade and give people a real reason to keep coming back, they'd implement machine specific leader boards. Imagine being invited to your friend's arcade to have a friendly game of Centipede and having a way to view high scores of only those who had played on that cabinet. I think that could make things much more personal for something that is supposed to recreate the social environment of the classic arcade. This, of course, would be supplemental to global leader boards; not a replacement, but it's a little thing that could go a long way.

To me, the most interesting idea of the Game Room is the chance to design my very own man cave to enjoy with friends. According to the Game Room fact sheet released by Microsoft, we can arrange cabinets how we want, as well as decorate the room with themes and animated icons from our favorite games. Unfortunately, we don't have many more details than that, but, depending on the level of customization and ease of use, this could be the bang for our buck that pushes some users over the edge and into consumer bliss.

Game Room is set to release this Spring, so we don’t have to wait long to see the master plan at work. Hopefully, this will be a positive experience for gamers and Microsoft alike.

Digg!

January 20, 2010

What is it about Achievements?

Jason Trent says Rewards systems are powerful things, and can help guide players in their purchases. Depending on which system you've invested the most amount of time on (the Xbox 360 or the PlayStation 3), you might find yourself drawn to one or the other on multi-platform games. I, for one, find that I purchase all of my multi-platform titles for the Xbox 360. Because I've spent a lot of time earning Achievements, I'd prefer to continue to increase my gamer score on that particular rewards system. Others feel connected to the trophy system, in which case they're going to be bound to purchase their multi-platform titles for the PlayStation 3. Without a doubt, this is something consumers consider when purchasing a game. What is it about these little beauties that make us tick? Why do so many of us spend so much time earning them, and what is it about them that makes us seek them out?

First and foremost, they make us feel good. They satisfy a compulsion to be rewarded for our actions. Most of us mull through life looking to get a pat on the head when we do well at something. It might be school, it might be work, it might be a relationship, but whatever it is, we need to feel like there's a reason for doing what we do; a reason that can often be found in the praise we receive. Getting an "Achievement Unlocked" message upon reaching the end of a level is just the carrot on a stick I need to keep me going sometimes.

Beyond the obvious point that achievements and trophies make us feel swell, they also represent your gaming resume; a scrapbook of sorts. Much like looking at photos of your last vacation, viewing a list of achievements or trophies you've earned can serve to remind you of some great times. They're a way to say, "I've been there. I've seen some stuff. I've done great things." Because we have something to show ourselves and others, they're validation that the time we've spent gaming wasn't a waste. Much the opposite in fact. Achievements and trophies allow us to bolster our sense of self-worth.

Besides being a system of rewards, achievements and trophies also supplement leader boards by providing a new way to compete with friends. I remember the first time I got into a friendly competition with someone (a co-worker) through achievements. I noticed that he was playing a lot of Call of Duty: World at War on Veteran difficulty. He'd already beaten a few levels, so I had to intervene. I caught up with him, then came to work the next day to gloat. From there, we'd each rush home after work each day to try to outdo the other, and for a change, work became fun. We'd share strategies, experiences, and frustrations (grenade spamming anyone?); things that really took my experience with the game to the next level. Eventually he got stuck on Vendetta (the fourth level), and I on Blowtorch & Corkscrew (the 12th level), but even if I wasn't able to finish the game, I still won the competition.

Achievements and trophies may seem simple on the surface, but there's more to them than meets the eye. I leave you with these questions: What are some of your favorite achievements or trophies and why? Do you prefer the acheivements system or trophies system and why?

Digg!

January 7, 2010

360 vs PS3 vs Wii: Who Won 2009?

Troy Benedict says In 2009, the game console with the most number of review scores of 90% or above was the PlayStation 3, according to MetaCritic.com.

Not only did the PS3 have the largest number of highly-reviewed titles, 9 to be exact, the list also contained 3 system exclusives: Uncharted 2: Among Thieves, God of War Collection, and Killzone 2.

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves was also the highest reviewed game of the year with an average of over 96%.

The 360 finished off the year in second place with 7 highly-reviewed titles. It's highest-rated game was Modern Warfare 2. Only 2 Xbox 360 exclusives made the list: Forza Motorsport 3 and the downloadable add-on Grand Theft Auto IV: The Lost and the Damned.

The Wii finished in third place with only one game held in the highest regards. That title was also a Wii exclusive: Metroid Prime Trilogy. [As a side note: somebody out there might ask, "What about New Super Mario Bros. Wii?" Based on average review scores of this publication, it averaged out at 87%. Not quite the shining beacon that Mario titles usually are.]

The multiplatform games that made both the PlayStation 3 and 360 list of best-reviewed games of 2009 were: Modern Warfare 2, Street Fighter IV, Batman: Arkham Aslyum, Assassin's Creed II, and FIFA Soccer 10.

Braid, released this year on PlayStation Network, was also among the PlayStation 3's highest-reviewed titles.

Compared to 2008's best-reviewed games, the Xbox 360 only had 5 titles. Only one was a system-exclusive (in retrospect): Gears of War 2. Braid for Xbox Live was also among those titles, which at the time could have been considered an Xbox exclusive, as a PS3 version hadn't been announced then.

The PlayStation 3 also had 5 titles in 2008, two of which were system exclusives: LittleBigPlanet and Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots.

The Wii followed with 3 games. Super Smash Bros. Brawl was the only true console-exclusive, however the WiiWare title World of Goo (also available at the time on PC) was also well-received.

What do we have to look forward to in 2010? I think there are many great things in store for the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3. There are many promising multiplatform titles coming out within the first quarter for both systems, like Bayonetta, Final Fantasy XIII, BioShock 2, Dark Void, Battlefield Bad Company 2, and Dante's Inferno. Q1 2010 also has some hotly anticipated system exclusives: Heavy Rain (PS3), Mass Effect 2 (360), MAG (PS3), Splinter Cell: Conviction (360), and God of War 3 (PS3).

I am a bit concerned about what the Wii will deliver in 2010. However, there are a few first-quarter titles worth mentioning: Tatsunoko vs. Capcom: Ultimate All Stars (which should appeal to core gamers), No More Heroes 2: Desperate Struggle, and Red Steel 2.

With all of these great titles coming out within the next three months, hopefully the rest of the year will be just as interesting and entertaining!

Digg!

November 14, 2009

The Disposable Console Era

Chris Nitz Says Atari 2600, Nintendo, Super Nintendo, Sega Genesis, Turbo Graphix 16, all of these are great gaming systems. Back in their heydays all there was to concern one's self with was what system to get. The Nintendo vs. Sega wars ran deep on many school yards.

When did consoles turn into something so disposable? At what point did consoles start becoming such a big decision on when and what to buy? PS3 40 Gig, 60 Gig, 20 Gig, huh? Xbox 360 Arcade, Pro, Elite what? Nintendo DS, DS Lite, DSi, DSi XL? Gamers should be up in arms over this.

Nintendo is really the culprit. They started the release-a-console, change-it-a-year-later, re-release it syndrome. Nintendo started this with the GameBoy, which was a thick, white brick and a battery hog. Yet, it was a huge success. A few years later, the GameBoy got a makeover with the GameBoy Pocket. This version was smaller, used less batteries, and really did fit in your pocket. This morphed into the GameBoy Color. The GameBoy Color was the same size as the GameBoy Pocket, but this new version sported a four-color screen.

The GameBoy redesign did not fix any issues. Sure, it was nice to have a smaller GameBoy, but there was nothing that it really fixed. Yet gamers flocked to this new design. It did not stop there though. Soon gamers saw more color options added. Special editions like the Pokemon themed GameBoy Pocket were released. Stores like EB/Gamestop had deals to get you to trade in your perfectly working systems to get a discount on the "New" system.

The Nintendo DS (DS) is the latest of Nintendo portables to go through revision after revision. When the DS was first released, it was rather large. It can also be argued that it was not the most attractive. The DS got its first revision in the DS Lite. This really got the DS off the ground. The DS Lite sold millions. It is still a leader in sales today. Not content with this, Nintendo released the Dsi, which was slightly bigger than the DS Lite. The DSi added a camera, but at the expense of removing the GameBoy Advance game slot. Yup, add a camera, but take away the backwards compatibility. This hurt those who bought Guitar Hero on the DS as there was no way to plug in the peripheral.

Still not happy, Nintendo recently announced the DSi XL. Really Nintendo!?!? It is bigger than the Dsi due to a larger screen. The DSi is not even a year old, and already they are releasing something new. Why not just release the bigger version right away? The people this hurts are those early adopters.

Sony has also joined in on this redesign fun. The PlayStation 2 (PS2) is their best selling system. When it was released, it was rather large. The PS2 came out with no hard drive nor network capabilities. Hard drive and ethernet accessories were later added so that users could get online and play Socom with their friends. Games like Final Fantasy XI and EverQuest Adventures also took advantage of both of these new accessories.

Then Sony released the PS2 slim. Again, this model really didn’t fix anything. It was a simple cosmetic change. However, the redesign made the hard drive and ethernet adapter obsolete. The PS2 Slim included an ethernet port, but no internal hard drive. This means those people who wanted to buy a PS2 Slim and continue to play EverQuest were SOL. Why do this?

The PlayStation 3 (PS3) is the newest of Sony's systems to get this treatment. The PS3 Slim was recently released. This system is 33% smaller than the original PS3. Yet again, it does not fix any issues except that it uses less power. Outside of that, there are no issues it really resolved. The one item PS3 fans have been asking for is to get PS2 compatibility. The PS3 Slim was not an answer to that hope.

Microsoft is not excluded from all this. The Xbox 360 has gone through several revisions and special editions. The 360 did not have an HDMI port when it was first released. This port was added on after the 360 received its first revision. In the era of HD gaming, the omission of the HDMI port is inexcusable.

There is one revision that does make sense though. The Nintendo Entertainment System (NES) got a top loading redesign. The top loading NES took queues from the Super Nintendo Entertainment System (SNES). The days of blowing in your NES cartridges and finagling them to play had come to an end. This was a smart redesign choice as it resolved an issue. The issue that it fixed was fighting with your NES games to get them to play. It is just a shame that this revision came along so late in the consoles life.

Where does all of this end? If gamers are not cautious and start putting an end to this, the options on new consoles will get ridiculous. The Xbox 720 could come in two different processors, three graphic card options, and all that would become obsolete a year later when the Xbox 720 Lite comes out.

You don't need to buy the light or slim versions of consoles. But at this rate, consoles will start having options that will be obsolete after its first revision. The first PS3 Slim revision could lead to more memory on the console. This would make games load faster, or even do away with load times. More graphic memory could be added, thus causing this revision to have better graphics.

Innovation is a good thing. Innovation that screws the early adopters, well that is just screwing the consumer. While most of the changes listed here can be argued as good changes, they come with a bit of caution to the early adopters. Buy the new console at your own risk, the next iteration could contain something that renders the current generation useless.

Editor’s Note: This article was focused on gaming systems, but Apple could easily fall into this debate with the iPod’s and iPhones. The bottom line is, buy what you want with the knowledge that next year there will be something better. If you’re not happy with the features a current model has, then just wait for the next generation. If you can’t wait and you need to have the newest model as soon as it comes out, then it’s a simple matter of buyer-beware.

As for when the Xbox 720 comes out, sure, I’ll want it. And I’m sure I’ll want it right away. But before I rush out and buy it I’m going to play all the games for the 360. By the time I’m done with that, maybe a better 720 will be out.

Digg!

November 3, 2009

Jurassic: The Hunted - First Impressions

Who would have thought the one with the mohawk would be the sensible one? Certainly not I. As Jurassic: The Hunted's intro movie plays and you're introduced to a small cast of characters, you meet one, non-mohawked weapons and survival expert named Craig Dylan. He seems like kind of a tool - even for a guy with two first names - so it's only natural that he's the main character. The other, mohawked military guy turns out to be the one in charge and does his best to calm Dylan down. I don't quite recall the name of the guy in charge and it doesn't really matter because he's going to die in a few moments, anyway. So much for pleasantries.


Dylan has been hired to protect a research team which, as best I can figure, is made up one of girl and her laptop. She's reading up on the Bermuda Triangle which is a great idea since the plane is currently flying through it... oh noes! Before long, the ride gets pretty bumpy and the three jump out of the plane, only to be caught up in some temporal disturbance and sent back in time; only, you don't know that, yet. I mean, I hope I'm not spoiling anything here but, just in case you haven't seen the cover art for Jurassic: The Hunted, there are dinosaurs inside. ROWAR!


Jurassic: The Hunted shares a name very similar to the movie Benji: The Hunted, only there's no cute little dog who saves a bunch of cougar cubs and no crazy hunter guy trying to kill them all, just lots and lots of dinosaurs. Also, the crazy hunter guy is you. Or are you the one being hunted? I'm not really sure, but you get a great assortment of guns to play with and almost no worry of ever running out of bullets. I mean, seriously, there are special crates in this game with an endless supply of bullets! Will the wonders of the Bermuda Triangle never cease?

The last thing Jurassic: The Hunted has to do with Benji: The Hunted is that, while each has the power to make me cry like a little girl, Jurassic: The Hunted does so for entirely different reasons. I kinda hate this game. A lot.


There are parts of Jurassic: The Hunted that make it feel like a dream-game come true. I found myself fully immersed in this fantasy, compelled to seek out stronger, more challenging prey. If you've ever fantasized about being lost in the jungle, trying to survive while testing your mettle against a T-Rex, then this game is for you! However, if the idea of being tackled by velociraptors while smaller, more pain-in-the-ass-to-kill dinosaurs chase you down at every turn also appeals to you, then, by all means, this is definitely the game for you. And don't forget those awesome "defend the fort" and turret scenes which crop up again and again! In less than five minutes, I survived defending an encampment from a gang of raptors only to round a corner and walk straight into the exact same scenario. "Didn't I just do this?" I wondered. And then, having survived that encounter, I came across a stationary gun and found myself forced to, once again, defend myself against a siege of raptors. Are you freaking kidding me? Is it possible that I've suffered a blunt head trauma and am simply experiencing the same memory over and over or are there really three "shoot the dinos as they run at you" scenarios within 5 minutes of walking distance in this game? Yes, unfortunately, there are.


I'm quite frightened of what the rest of this game could hold for me in terms of velociraptor gang-rape scenarios. Seriously, these guys are a bunch of a**holes. They don't let up and the eons that pass between pressing the "reload" button and the unloading of your weapon upon them is appalling. Your best bet is to simply run the hell away as fast as you can and hope they just get tired of picking on you. It's a lot like high school.


When all is said and done, the pretty graphics do lend a lot towards making this game an enjoyable experience. Witnessing the majesty in a herd of virtual brachiosaurs walking through a field is inspiring. It looks a lot better than it had to and almost causes you to completely forget that, hey, this game is also available on Wii and PlayStation 2! Just in case you do completely forget, though, the gameplay is always there to remind you - one raptor rape scene at a time. Jurassic: The Hunted is a budget game, and based on what I've seen so far, it falls well within the "Average" to "Below Average" range. Make of that what you will; at least it's not as bad as Darkest of Days.


Digg!

November 2, 2009

Borderlands final review

Dale Culp says: My first impression of Borderlands - which you can read here - turned out to be a lasting one. This is a fun, terrific game with all the trappings of an MMO but without the stale fantasy setting that turns players like me off almost immediately. Borderlands is, essentially, World of Warcraft for the Halo crowd. It's also representative of a trend we're going to be seeing a lot more of with games like Brink that promise an excellent multiplayer experience that feels as tight as a single player one. Gamers have been wanting something other than sword and sorcery style role-playing and this is pretty much it. However, I believe I've praised the game enough in my first impression piece, so now I'll point out some frustration I've been having with Borderlands because, unfortunately, it's not perfect.


I started a custom multiplayer game with the hopes of attracting some fun people to play with. As much as I like to gripe about the people I bump into on Xbox Live, most of the players who joined my game were civil and courteous. I even managed to add a few more gamers to my friends list and had a great time. This is, really, the best way to experience Borderlands. We gang-up on tough bosses, tell jokes while sharing loot and tea-bag the poor Claptraps we encounter while waiting for each player to get ready before transitioning to a new area. Under the right circumstances, Borderlands never stops being fun. Under the wrong circumstances, however, it's a complete mess.


I was on a tough quest, heading into a section with some pretty high ranking enemies who'd managed to make short work of me. Pinned behind some boxes, I was waiting for my shield to recharge and hoping to get a few clear shots on the bandits as I stood and saw one running towards me. I heard the sound of rocket fire and thought, "Just what I need. They have rockets, too." The rocket's explosion did not result in my impending doom, however, as I watched the bandit quickly reduced to fiery bits of hamburger.


Wait a second, who fired that rocket?


In the firefight, I hadn't noticed that 3 other players joined the game. "You really saved my bacon," I said, but there was no reply. Instead, the 3 other players, each at level 50, just ran past me, painting the canyon walls with bits of bandit and plenty of gore. Within seconds, they had taken down the boss and finished the quest. I didn't even have a chance to reload my weapon.


The disappointment I felt in watching total strangers play my game for me - claiming all the glory and taking all the loot on their way out the door - wasn't the kicker, though. The worst part came after two of the players left, leaving me with an over-aggressive mouth-breather who just wanted to duel. I walked to the transition point, ignoring his requests, and tried to leave when the countdown was canceled. In Borderlands, if you want to cancel transitioning to another area in the game, all you have to do is hit the "back" button on your Xbox 360 controller to bring up the menu. This other player then returned to slashing me with his melee attack, insisting that we duel. Seriously. This person is a jackass. How is it ever fun, or even remotely a challenge, to duel with someone at level 25 - literally half your level? Even if I went ahead with it, even if I had a real chance at beating him, what would I gain? I guess it's a good way of settling disputes and blowing off steam between players who give a crap about such things, but mostly, the duel system in Borderlands reveals plenty of opportunity for griefing. When it became painfully clear that I wasn't going to be allowed to leave, my response was to kick the player out of the game and shut it down for the night. I'd had enough.


I expected this of the multiplayer game, which is why I wasn't in such a hurry to jump into it. This problem isn't isolated to Borderlands, by any means, but when a game like this simply begs to be played multiplayer, it's an unfortunate consequence that you're going to have to deal with if you want to get the most out of it. In short, play with friends for the best experience because there is just so much to do. Accepting one quest can often lead to several more, on top of the several you have waiting for you at the job boards and other non-player characters. Very often you'll assume you've tapped an area out completely only to turn in that last quest and suddenly become inundated with nearly a dozen more. I'm not knocking the game for having plenty to do, but without friends along to make the experience fun, it can get tedious. Thankfully, you can play the game splitscreen or through the system link, making the multiplayer experience available even without Xbox Live. Also, the light-hearted writing makes the story fun and interesting even if you don't have friends to play with you. Like in my first impression, I find myself laughing more than cursing this game and that's why I'll keep playing for a while, only going online when I'm feeling particularly adventurous.


One of my favorite features in Borderlands is the "bleeding out/second wind" feature. Instead of dying and being sent back to the last save point as soon as your health runs out, you have a few seconds to kill the enemy who knocked you down. If you can manage that, you get a "second wind" which gives you just enough shield and health to flee or keep fighting. Sometimes, however, it doesn't always work as planned. Sometimes you kill an enemy right before losing all your health and you're left fighting nothing with no hope of a second wind. Other times, you fall in such an awkward position that you can't return fire and are simply left to die. In a multiplayer game, you can use the "bleeding out/second wind" feature as an opportunity to heal a fallen comrade, or hope they come to rescue you. It's an interesting take on the idea of death in a game and can save you quite a lot of time and money.


Borderlands is quite worthy of the high praise I've given it but the few flaws it has definitely keep it from receiving a perfect score. It can get pretty lonely out there in the single player mode and the overwhelming number of quests may have you wondering if it will ever end, but it does so well to avoid taking itself seriously that you have a great time in spite of the grind. Borderlands also taps right into that loot-gathering part of the brain which makes it so addictive that it's extremely hard to put down. I can't recommend this game enough, it's definitely one I'll be playing for a long time.


Digg!

October 28, 2009

The Fall 2009 Dashboard Update

Shawn Lebert Says “And here we go.” As Heath Ledger would dramatically say when something amazing would happen – God rest his soul – just moments later. A new update for the Xbox 360 is coming to everyone very soon but only the few, only the wonderfully chosen, were selected into the delightful world of the beta version.

The Fall update, announced at this year’s E3, will include social networking at its finest on the 360 console. Don’t have a computer nearby and are just dying to tweet about the back-story of the creation of your ham sandwich? You will have all the necessities at your fingertips through your beloved gaming system.

I, Sleebs (LIVE gamertag), have been honored with the pleasure of the update of social splendor. Is the update worth waiting for? Better yet, is it worth tweeting over? I’ll break down what’s important to the update and theorize what could have been implemented better.

TWITTER
So you’re a tweeting whore. Who’s not these days? Everywhere I look, my gamer buds are updating their gamer experiences with their personal twitter apps. And what’s more perfect than combining Twitter networking with the Xbox 360?

All you need is a Twitter account and a log-in. Before you know it, you’ll be viewing your tweets. The auto-update feature refreshes your tweet feed quickly, so you’re never missing out on anyone’s comments.

The twitter page is basic, having your Twitter name at the top of the list to the left – in case you just so happen to forget who you are. What’s cool is that your avatar is sitting atop of everything. Much like the regular Xbox dashboard, your avatar will naturally blink, move, and animate here and there throughout.

Underneath your name is the, “What are you doing option,” which allows you to type in a status update right away. I noticed upon first impression that, hey, you’re going to need a chat-pad immediately. If not, Twitter will get annoying. Punching letters and numbers individually will be painstaking and annoying otherwise.

Below the status update feature, you have the Search option, which allows you to search for keywords within the twitter realm.

Lastly, the Trending Topics area is a listing of all the – you guessed it! – trendy topics on twitter. By clicking on a trendy topic of your choosing, you are sent to a current list of the people who recently mentioned the keyword within their status update.

On the right hand side, you’ll see your personal list of all the latest tweets. Quick and simple. The design layout is very elementary and complimentary to what you’d see on twitter, including various clouds that animate and move in the background.

What Can Be Improved to Twitter
Much of this feature can be improved dramatically. Even though there’s nothing wrong with it, there’s nothing that provides a reason why you’d use it on the Xbox. Everyone in this day and age has the ability to use a computer. Twitter has sweeped the nation with its remarkable simplicity. By now, Twitter has managed to migrate to not just sites, but mobile hardware like phones and whatnot. Twitter is a standard program for many: a direct stream of twitter feeds being downloaded to your desktop with ease.

Why stare at twitter when the Xbox 360 is supposed to be a game console? Granted, it’s becoming a multimedia system, but are we going to study a screen without doing something else in the process? Twitter has become the background application.

Another issue is that since the Xbox 360 doesn’t have a built-in browser, the links that friends update with are utterly useless since you can’t click on them.

Given its early stages, it would be interesting to get pop-ups on your Xbox Live regarding a game status or just a tweet that you made when you are doing something else on the 360. The computer has this beat easily.

FACEBOOK
Yet another really convenient way to communicate with friends, family, alumni, or anyone else! Once you sign into Facebook through the 360, you’re given a similar tile structure to that of the basic Xbox dashboard. The categories are broken up into Home, Photos, Friends, and Profile. Within the Home area, you’ll see the latest status updates, how many have liked the comment or written in to comment back to the original poster.

Depending on how many categories for people you have will determine how many feed tiles there will be on the home page.

Underneath the Home category, you have Photos. Here, you can view your photos or even your friends’ photos that are public to view.

After that is the Friends area, where you can peruse each friend on your list and view their updates, photos and info.

Interested in commenting back to a friend’s status? Just click the appropriate tile and you’ll be given the option to comment back. Easy schmeasy.

What Can be Improved to Facebook
The decision to make the Facebook appearance as tiled, like the Xbox dashboard, feels odd. It’s like they had to use the dashboard tiles because there was no other way to use Facebook any other way.

There seems to be so many tiles that it looks like they could have condensed them. It’s good that they kept the key categories for each major area, but all the tiles are confusing. You’re better off just selecting the first tile in each category and find the appropriate thing to select within the sub-menu.

Usually, if you’re near your Xbox, you’d be near your laptop or computer – which happens to be much more convenient to peruse from an Internet browser than this mess. Yes, mess.

LAST.FM
Last.fm is perhaps the coolest way to listen to music. Have a favorite band but don’t know a lot of similar artists? Last.fm is there to do that for you, as you can stream bands or singers that work within the same genre, and it’s that easy.


I think that Last.fm is the most special feature that this update has to offer since it’s all about the music and it’s free. Well, that is, for Gold members on Xbox Live.

Last.fm is set up with the tile system like the Xbox dashboard, but it works here between popular stations and starting your own station. You can scroll through the popular stations that people are dancing to right at this moment and begin enjoying it with them.

If you aren’t really interested in what’s popular, you can set up your own station given that you provide an artist that you’d like to listen to.

The dashboard tile appearance also works to separate all the artists you have scrobbled onto your last.fm account. By clicking on the specific artist tile, you go right into buffering their station and its similar artists.

What’s really fascinating is the way the music plays. Since it’s just audio, last.fm has provided images on your screen so that you can enjoy the tracks while getting a screensaver effect, over a random set of pictures already looping on your console.

A little browser underneath it – similar to the Xbox video – gives you options like Info, Skip and Stop. You can also heart it, meaning that if you love the track that’s currently playing, it will set up in your loved-tracks list on your account.

A popular way to play music is here.

What Can Be Improved to Last.fm
This is a big critical annoyance to me, but why oh why can’t I back out of the Last.fm area and just play Last.fm anywhere on my Xbox? Whether I’m just on the dash itself or playing a video game, there should be many ways to play Last.fm, and it would be a more significant way to play music if anyone were to do this. Since you can only play Last.fm within Last.fm, that means you cannot venture within the Xbox while listening. Most people have music playing in the background while they do other things. This feature needs to be implemented; otherwise, Last.fm will hardly be used.

One of the great features of the music player on the Xbox 360 is the ability to play music while playing a video game. What’s even much cooler is that music blends into your gameplay; taking out the video game’s musical score itself and slaps the music you’re playing on top, creating a seamless blend of perfection. One could only wish Last.fm could do the very same.

Unfortunately, as great as Last.fm is capable of, it’s usually pointless to stare at a screen, unless you are using it to play within the background. But by this time, anyone has set up their computers to do this already. So why use the Xbox 360 for it?

ZUNE MARKETPLACE
The Zune Marketplace is the last feature to the update, but still utilizes the Zune marketplace that the Zune is already capable of, just now with the affiliation of your 360. With current films like Drag Me to Hell and Fast and Furious already up, it’s tempting to see what else is there on the list.

The key feature to the Zune Marketplace is the ability to watch streaming full-HD 1080p. Always been wanting Blu-ray on the 360? Well, here’s a partial answer that might help satisfy the appetite. Crystal-clear image never looked better and the experience is truly worth waiting for.

Not only can you experience movies, but there’s also television, music videos, and independent video. Start a party with some friends and watch it together. Not sure what to watch? Why not try some movie trailers for current and upcoming films?

What Can Be Improved to Zune
Well, aside from the fact that Netflix can already do 75% of what the Zune marketplace can, there isn’t really a lot of incentive. The only difference is you can decide on buying or renting a film. Another positive factor with the Zune marketplace is the 1080p playback, which is worthy of experiencing . With Netflix being a full-on service with many Instant Play films already, there’s some competition.

With both Netflix and the Zune Marketplace, it’s difficult to decide which feature to utilize most, but at least you have a choice. If you have a need to buy a film, Zune Marketplace is there. Either way, it’s seems like there’s conflict with where you should be spending your money, time, and hard drive space.

Conclusion
While it seems like a crazy-cool update with some interesting tidbits, it’s nothing that the computer or laptop can’t already do. If you’re this invested in sitting in front of an Xbox 360, you’re bound to be sitting with your PC or Mac nearby anyway. Although, while it is fancy that the 360 can work with these sites, you’ll find that the simple and quicker function rests with your trusty computer.

Until we see a complete integration of these features, they don’t add much to the Xbox Live Experience, but it is still good to have compatibility nonetheless.

Executive Editor's Note: I only add my commentary to articles that I really hate and the articles that I really love. With that said, this is an article that I really love (deep down inside I love all the articles that I publish... uh, huh). Anyway, being that I am not privy to the beta of the Fall Update, I found this article to be very informative, and also very disappointing (in the updates, not in the writing of the article itself).

It appears that good ole Microsoft went nine yards and failed to make the first down. They popped out to left field and Manny Ramirez caught the lazy fly ball. Ok, that's enough sports metaphors (I swear, I've only had two glasses of wine, OK, they were double glasses, but still, that's only four glasses of wine and now I'm rambling...).

What I'm trying to say is, wouldn't it be cool to be playing a game, have Last.fm playing in the background, have your tweets and FB notifications pop on the screen like Achievements, and have Zune, well, I guess have Zune be Zune... What I'm trying to say is: Microsoft, if you want to score the goal, then you need full integration. If you want the slam dunk, then you gotta take it to the hoop. You know what I'm sayin? If you're gonna do something, then do it right. Half-ass effort gets you half-ass results. And while I'm on this rant, just drop Last.fm and incorporate iTunes or Pandora (can't we all just get along?).

My apologies to Sleebs for this rant...

Digg!


September 21, 2009

Darkest of Days Review

Dale Culp says When I first came across Darkest of Days, I thought it looked really interesting. Even if it turned out to be a mediocre shooter, at least the story seemed promising. I had no idea I was about to step straight into the most appalling dung heap of a game imaginable.


Things go wrong for this game immediately. The start menu, alone, looks like it would be an embarrassment to even the most amateur of video game producers. A few flat buttons, a logo and a picture of an old rifle set against a black background; if that's the best 8Monkey Labs can muster for even such a tiny detail, than it's hard to hold out hope for the rest of the game. And yet, as much as I refuse to judge this game by its cover and look for something better inside, sadly, things don't pick up very much, at all.


The game begins at Little Big Horn, where a man named Alexander Morris is about to meet his fate. It's Custer's Last Stand, and Morris isn't playing on the winning team. This is the one thing 8Monkey Labs gets absolutely right – you are thrust right into the action without warning. No time is wasted as the game starts off with a huge bang. You get very little explanation of what's going on aside from your only orders from a fellow soldier: “shoot as many injuns as you can.” Your heart is already racing and the game has only just begun!


As the battle climaxes, you are mortally wounded and left sitting on the ground. Unable to move, all you can do is fire your pistol into the onslaught of... Native Americans, if you will. Suddenly, atop the hill, the stark image of a man's silhouette standing against the bright sun stumbles and falls. General Custer is dead, and you're about to join him when a flash of light draws your attention away from the battle. Standing in front of you, a man in futuristic battle armor tells you to follow him. You step through the time portal and that's when the game begins proper. If a journey of a thousand miles must begin with a single step, this was a great step to start on.


Essentially, what's happened is that you've been culled from the battlefield only moments from death to be recruited by the agents of KronoteK. Back in your time, your papers were lost and no one knows you were at the Battle of Little Big Horn. History lists you as M.I.A. - just another unsolved mystery. Thanks to KronoteK, you've been given a second chance at life. The price for this second chance, however, is that it's now your job to go back and fix other problems that have been cropping up in history. These problems include soldiers, generals and other people getting killed before their time, winding up in battles they should have never been fighting in the first place. For the first few missions, you escort some of the characters away from the battlefield, to safety. In other missions, you simply protect and guide leaders so that they win their particular battle. In some cases, it doesn't always go as planned; in other cases, you learn that a rogue team of time agents have been messing with the timeline on purpose. Ah! The plot thickens. The fact that Morris is completely cool with this entire situation, however, kinda skews the whole thing into absurdity. Time travel? Computers? Advanced weaponry and electronics? Oh, I'm sure this was all par for the course for your average Union soldier who, only moments ago, was about to meet his maker. Nothing more to see here; move along.


Now, one of the more tricky things about time travel is that you can't predict the outcome of your actions – kill the wrong person and you might radically change the future. How, then, do you present this as a challenge in a video game? The answer is simple: you paint the characters who must be saved in a blue “aura.” It adds an interesting twist to the gameplay because the people who must be saved are on the side of the force you're trying to stop. Meanwhile, the guy painted in blue and all of his friends are shooting at you. And not only do you have to avoid killing them, you also have to keep your comrades from killing them, as well. You can either knock them out by hitting them with the butt of your rifle or use a special, futuristic weapon that knocks them out remotely. Your reward for saving these individuals are points you can put towards upgrading your weapons. The argument is that, the less you screw up time, the more time the agents have to work on your weapons instead of fixing the problems you caused in the timeline – and believe me, you want them to improve your weapons. An inaccurate, single shot musket that takes 30 seconds or more to load gets very, very annoying. Faster rates of fire, better accuracy and larger clips are just a few of the upgrades you can buy, and you'll want every one of them.


To further change the game up a bit, Dexter – the agent who saved you and has been helping you in these missions – shows up with some fancy bit of weaponry that gives you the ultimate advantage. At one point in the Battle of Antietam, he hands you a high-powered machine gun and tells you to “turn the tide.” It actually ends up being one of the most gratifying parts of the whole game. As droves of Confederate soldiers rush at you from out of the cornfield with single-shot muskets, you simply mow them down. For a moment, the gameplay in Darkest of Days actually approaches fun, but then quickly retreats and isn't seen again for a long, long time.


Among the most egregious flaws in this game is the incredibly stupid artificial intelligence. On the missions where Dexter accompanies you, he simply stands by as enemies ignore him to shoot you in the face. Then you have the weapons, which are all just terrible, but that's kind of the whole point of this game - to see what it was like to fight with ancient weapons. The voice acting is lousy, although Dexter's is passable - except that they give him some of the worst lines in the game. Lines so bad that you'd swear they were the result of poor translation if not for the fact that this game started in English. Speaking of which, I do appreciate the use of native languages. Rather than some lousy faux-Russian or German accent, they actually did the dialogue in those languages. But then you have the awful graphical glitches, low frame-rate, texture compression, poor animation and other problems that constantly come up and ruin every good idea this game ever had. Darkest of Days feels like a rushed, half-assed attempt to create a game for as little as possible. Based on the technical faults, alone, no one should ever pay money for this game. But then, it's just no fun, either. It's an endlessly frustrating experience that only gets worse as it goes on. This game should have never come out in the condition it's in.


Darkest of Days reeks of wasted potential. The story and the concept gave me the impression that 8Monkey Labs was going for something along the lines of Quantum Leap but ended up producing The Time Tunnel instead. (Look it up... Irwin Allen was the king of low-budget, campy science-fiction television.) The irony is, I actually like old, campy sci-fi flicks. In fact, during the first few hours of this game, I found myself laughing at all the problems. Like watching an old monster movie where you can see the zippers on the costumes and the strings holding up the UFOs, it was so bad it was good. But then it turned. It started getting really bad and added plot elements that made me wonder if this was a clumsy attempt at a history lesson or a very distasteful use of actual events. Combined with the technical flaws and the completely frustrating gameplay experience, I stopped laughing. To put it another way, it felt like watching Schindler's List as directed by Lloyd Kaufman. Serious history combined with bad taste and poor skill. I was not impressed. In short, do not buy this game. In fact, don't even waste your money renting or trading for it on Goozex - it's that bad.


Digg!

September 14, 2009

360 vs PS3 - Which Offers the Better Games?

Troy Benedict Says Welcome to part 3 of the pound-per-pound comparison of the Xbox 360 and the PlayStation 3. In the first part of the series, I compared each system's online experience. In the second part, the home theater aspects of each machine were discussed. For this article, I will compare both console's game library, and determine which system offers the best games. What constitutes a good game or a bad game is very subjective, so for this comparison I went to Metacritic's web site and took a snapshot on September 4, 2009 of the entire list of review scores for each system's available games. The results were broken down into three categories:

  1. Multiplatform Titles - games that have been released for both consoles.
  2. Exclusive Titles - games that are available only on one console. They are exclusive, whether it a current timed-exclusive or an indefinite exclusivity. These can include disc-based releases or downloadable games (PlayStation Network or Xbox Live Arcade titles, for example).
  3. Total Games Library - this is a combination of exclusive and multiplatform games released for both consoles.

Within each category, you will see two tables of information:

  1. The first table breaks down the totals and averages for that category based on the titles' review score ranges. For example, you can see the average review score for games that scored between an 80 and 89 rating, the number of games that were rated within that 80-90 point range, and the percentage of titles that averaged between an 80-89 score compared to the other score ranges of that particular category (multiplatform, exclusive, or total library).

  2. The second table breaks down the review scores, for each category, based on the year that game was released, and the average review score.

Each category will also have the overall averages for each system, as well as the list of top-rated games per console. For the multiplatform and exclusive releases I have included each console's lowest-rated game -- just for fun!

Multiplatform Titles:
Multiplatform games are available on both the Xbox 360 or the PlayStation 3.

Of the 263 games available on both systems, the Xbox 360 average score is .7 points higher than the PlayStation 3's.

Average Review Score (Out of 100) For Multiplatform Titles

  • Xbox 360: 71.1
  • PlayStation 3: 70.4



Highest-Rated Multiplatform Games:

Xbox 360:

  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) - Average Score:98

PlayStation3:

  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) - Average Score:98

Best Xbox 360 Multiplatform Games (Average Score 90 or greater):

  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) Average Score: 98
  • BioShock (2008) Average Score: 96
  • Orange Box, The (2007) Average Score: 96
  • Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, The (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Street Fighter IV (2009) Average Score: 93
  • Fallout 3 (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Rock Band (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Rock Band 2 (2008) Average Score: 92
  • Batman: Arkham Asylum (2009) Average Score: 92

Best PlayStation 3 Multiplatform Games (Average Score 90 or greater):

  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) Average Score: 98
  • BioShock (2008) Average Score: 94
  • Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Street Fighter IV (2009) Average Score: 94
  • Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, The (2007) Average Score: 93
  • Rock Band (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Rock Band 2 (2008) Average Score: 91
  • Fallout 3 (2008) Average Score: 90
  • Batman: Arkham Asylum (2009) Average Score: 90
  • Guitar Hero 5 (2009) Average Score: 90

Lowest-Rated Multiplatform Games

Xbox 360:

  • Leisure Suit Larry: Box Office Bust (2009) - Average Score: 25

PlayStation3:

  • Leisure Suit Larry: Box Office Bust (2009) - Average Score: 18

There has been a long-standing debate about whether or not the Xbox 360 offers a better version releases.

The stats do not lie. The averages of all multiplatform releases do favor the Xbox 360. However, the differences are so insignificant with less than a 1 point difference.

Both systems have the same highest and lowest scoring games, GTA4 and Leisure Suit Larry: Box Office Bust, respectively.

The review scores were very similar. 90% of the games varied by a 4-point, or less, difference in review scores.Of the 263 compared multiplatform games:

  • 45 games received the same average review score.
  • 89 games received a 1-point difference average review scores.
  • 48 games received a 2-point difference average review scores.
  • 31 games received a 3-point difference average review scores.
  • 23 games received a 4-point difference average review scores.
  • 27 games received a 5-point or greater difference in the average review scores.
  • F.E.A.R. was the game with the biggest discrepancy, a 13-point difference. The game was released in 2006 for the Xbox 360 and received an average score of 85. It was released on the PlayStation 3 in 2007 and received an average score of 72.
  • 133 games were reviewed higher on the Xbox 360 by an average of 2.7 points.
  • 85 games were reviewed higher on the PlayStation 3 by an average of 2.1 points.

Xbox 360 enthusiasts may be pleased to know that their system edges out the competition with a VERY slight edge, and they have more higher-reviewed games, but here is an interesting fact. The 360 had the better multiplatform games in 2006, 2007, and 2008, but the PlayStation 3 is offering is dominating this year's multiplatform releases.Verdict
The numbers don't lie. Even if it's a slight advantage, the Xbox 360 offers the better multiplatform experience over the PlayStation 3. However, if the trend continues in the table above, the PlayStation 3 may very well offer the better experience for 2009's releases.

Exclusive Titles

Average Review Score (Out of 100) For System Exclusive Title:

  • Xbox 360: 66.4 (433 games)
  • PlayStation 3: 72.0 (127 games)


Highest-Rated Exclusive Game(s)
Xbox 360:

  • Gears of War (2006) - Average Score: 94
  • Halo 3 (2007) - Average Score: 94

PlayStation3:

  • LittleBigPlanet (2008) - Average Score:95

Best Xbox 360 Exclusive Games (Average Score 90 or greater):

  • Gears of War (2006) Average Score: 94
  • Halo 3 (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Braid (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Gears of War 2 (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Guitar Hero II (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Mass Effect (2007) Average Score: 91
  • Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter (2006) Average Score: 90
  • Grand Theft Auto IV: The Lost and Damned (2009) Average Score: 90
  • Portal: Still Alive (2008) Average Score: 90
  • Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved 2 (2008) Average Score: 90
  • Forza Motorsport 2 (2007) Average Score: 90

Best PlayStation 3 Exclusive Games (Average Score of 90 or greater):

  • LittleBigPlanet (2008) Average Score: 95
  • Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots (2008) Average Score: 94
  • Killzone 2 (2009) Average Score: 91
  • MLB 09: The Show (2009) Average Score: 90

Lowest-Rated Exclusive Game(s)
Xbox 360:

  • Yaris (2007) - Average Score: 17
PlayStation 3:
  • Vampire Rain: Altered Species (2008) - Average Score: 30
    Note: Vampire Rain is also available on Xbox 360, but this version features content not included in the 360 release, hence making it an exclusive title.
It might be shocking to see such a stark difference between the exclusive 360 releases and those on the PlayStation 3. The PlayStation is leading the march with a 72 point average versus the Xbox's 66.4. That quite a significant lead!


There is a reason for the 360's lower averages: the Xbox Live Arcade releases. The Xbox 360 offers a significantly larger number exclusive titles, more than 3 times what can only be purchased for a PlayStation, but a majority of those releases are less-than-stellar Xbox Live Arcade games. As you can see from the details above, Xbox 360's lowest-rated exclusive was, in fact, the free Xbox Live Arcade title Yaris.

Year to year, the Xbox 360 has offered more exclusives, almost 4 times as many in 2007, than the PlayStation 3. The Xbox 360 also has a significantly larger number of top-rated exclusive games, with 11 titles compared to PlayStation 3's 4 games.


Verdict
To be truly honest, the real answer to who wins the exclusive games category can't be made by dissecting review scores. The idea behind exclusivity is to offer something that the other guy doesn't have, in order to generate interest in your product over the competition's. Exclusives all come down to preference, and each system offers experiences that can't be made on the other system.

Based on numbers alone, the PlayStation 3 has a much higher average review score for it's exclusive titles. That being said, the PS3 also offers less than one-third of the exclusive games found on the 360.


Is it better to have a larger number of games to choose from -- with a guaranteed Xbox 360 Arcade release (or two, or three) each week? Or do you go with less variety and a slightly higher quality?

In situations like these, it makes me glad to own both systems.


Total Games Library (All Releases)

Average Review Score (Out of 100) For All Releases:
  • Xbox 360: 68.2 (696 games)
  • PlayStation 3: 70.9 (390 games)
Best of the Xbox 360 (Average Score 90 or greater):
  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) Average Score: 98
  • BioShock (2007) Average Score: 96
  • Orange Box, The (2007) Average Score: 96
  • Gears of War (2006) Average Score: 94
  • Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, The (2006) Average Score: 94
  • Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Halo 3 (2007) Average Score: 94
  • Braid (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Street Fighter IV (2009) Average Score: 93
  • Fallout 3 (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Gears of War 2 (2008) Average Score: 93
  • Guitar Hero II (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Rock Band (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Batman: Arkham Asylum (2009) Average Score: 92
  • Rock Band 2 (2008) Average Score: 92
  • Mass Effect (2007) Average Score: 91
  • Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter (2006) Average Score: 90
  • Grand Theft Auto IV: The Lost and Damned (2009) Average Score: 90
  • Portal: Still Alive (2008) Average Score: 90
  • Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved 2 (2008) Average Score: 90
  • Forza Motorsport 2 (2007) Average Score: 90

Best of the PlayStation 3 (Average Score 90 or greater):

  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) Average Score: 98
  • LittleBigPlanet (2008) Average Score: 95
  • Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare (2007) Average Score: 94
  • BioShock (2008) Average Score: 94
  • Street Fighter IV (2009) Average Score: 94
  • Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots (2008) Average Score: 94
  • Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, The (2007) Average Score: 93
  • Rock Band (2007) Average Score: 92
  • Rock Band 2 (2008) Average Score: 91
  • Killzone 2 (2009) Average Score: 91
  • Batman: Arkham Asylum (2009) Average Score: 90
  • Fallout 3 (2008) Average Score: 90
  • MLB 09: The Show (2009) Average Score: 90
  • Guitar Hero 5 (2009) Average Score: 90
Verdict
The Total Games Library is a combination of both the exclusives and multiplatform games.


Numbers don't lie, but they don't always tell the whole truth, either. The numbers say that the PlayStation 3 offers the better overall experience. The trend in multiplatform games in 2009 seems to favor the PlayStation 3 as of early September. Does the fact that the 360 has 21 games with an average score of 90 or greater, compared to PS3's 14, make any difference? Or that the 360 offers the larger number of exclusives games by more than 300 titles? Or that the 360 had a year's head-start?

I'm going to leave it up to you, dear reader, to decide the final answer on this one. I, like the lawyer, present to you, the judge and jury, the facts.


Next up, the final comparison: each system's unique hardware offerings.

Digg!

September 8, 2009

360 vs PS3 - Which Offers a Better Home Theater Experience?

Troy Benedict Says Welcome to part two of my comparison of the Xbox 360 Elite and the PlayStation 3. This article will focus on which system offers the optimal home theater experience.

I will briefly go over the structure of this series. During the comparison I will first look at the simple facts of each category and pass a judgment based only on the facts. I will then take a deeper look at each system's strengths and weaknesses in each category. For example, I will offer a counter-point in some instances or discuss any hidden fees or required accessories that aren't mentioned in the simple facts.

Most people might immediately think that the PlayStation 3 is the better deal, simply for Blu-ray. But is it really? Simple Facts:
  • The PS3 and Xbox 360 can play CD and DVD format discs.
  • Both can be easily set up to stream video over a home network, from a Windows-based PC running Windows Media Player 11.
  • Both can output resolutions of up to 1080p.
  • Both systems have standard and high-definition television and movie content that can be "rented" from their respective online video service. Each video services has some exclusive content only viewable on that console.
  • Only the PS3 has the option to buy and own select digital movies from its online video service.
  • Only the PS3 can play high definition Blu-ray discs.
  • The Xbox 360 can play HD-DVD formatted discs by using the official HD-DVD drive, however the HD-DVD format is no longer supported.
  • On average, Blu-ray titles are significantly more expensive than the DVD version.
  • Both systems have one HDMI port.
  • Only the PS3 has an optical digital output port.
  • Both systems come packaged with standard definition cables. HDMI or component cables require additional purchases.
  • The Xbox 360 has Netflix integration, but requires a Gold membership and a Netflix account to use.

Judgment: Blu-ray is a really good selling point for the PlayStation 3. However, you're not going to experience the benefits of Blu-ray unless you have an HD television and either an HDMI or component cable.

On standard definition television, using the included composite cables, both systems are equal.

However, on high definition televisions, the PlayStation 3 is the better deal, hands down.

Deeper Look: Both the Xbox 360 and the PlayStation 3 are capable of high resolution graphics and video, but neither system comes packed with the required cables. The non-Arcade versions of the Xbox 360 used to come packaged with a set of component cables, but this is no longer the case with the new Xbox 360 Elite packages. I find it a little more forgiving for the Xbox 360 not to come packaged with any HD cable, simply because it doesn't have a high-definition disc drive. The PlayStation 3, however, because of it's Blu-ray functionality should, in my opinion, come packaged with at least a set of component cables. Essentially, some additional costs are required for high-definition, regardless of which system you own.

It is a fact that only the PlayStation 3 can play high-definition Blu-ray discs out-of-the-box. But is it also a fact that both the 360 and PS3 systems can play DVDs, and both can upscale DVDs to 1080p (but the end product isn’t as crisp and clear as true high-def, as should be expected). DVD is still the most popular and accessible video disc format, despite what popular online retailer's top-ten lists may say. Most popular movies will see a Blu-ray release, but not all content released on video will make it to Blu-ray. Standalone Blu-ray movie releases are typically $10 more than the DVD equivalent, and are $20-30, if not significantly more, for boxed sets.

The Xbox and PlayStation offer premium video content in both standard and high definition versions. Both systems have exclusive movies and television series that can only be watched on the respective system. Typically, rentals run no more than $6. The PlayStation store allows users to purchase and own select movies for around $15. Some titles are available for cheaper. The Xbox 360 does not offer a download-to-own services for movies.

The Xbox gold members with Netflix accounts can watch any available Netflix Instant Watch movies or television series. An annual subscription for a gold membership is $50 and the cheapest Netflix membership runs about $10 per month.

The Netflix Instant Watch began as an option for Netflix members to watch a movie instantly from their computer’s web browser, and has grown to integrate itself with other hardware systems, namely the Xbox 360.

The Netflix integration was included with last year's major update to the Xbox 360 dashboard, nicknamed The NXE (New Xbox Experience). Since then, the available video catalog has grown tremendously and the functionality of Netflix on the Xbox has improved greatly.

Entire seasons of television shows and a larger selection of movies are available to watch in HD through the Instant Watch. Improvements to the streaming service, included with this year's most recent update, load movies much faster than they ever have, and even those who have slower broadband connections, now claim to be able to watch HD content without issue.

While the selection of quality titles and variety of available HD-content via Netflix Instant Watch is impressive, only a very small percentage of popular titles are actually available in this format. As I write this article, only 4 titles of Netflix's Top 100 list are available to watch through Instant Watch. 4%, no matter how you spin it, is a VERY low percentage.

I truly and honestly think that that digital distribution is going to be the way of the future, but it’s going to take time. One only needs to look to music distribution services like iTunes, Zune, and Amazon to see how viable this option is. Xbox and PlayStation both have a tremendous library of games available only for download, and both have an ever increasing catalog of video on-demand content from their respective video stores, both in standard and high-definition. With digital content, one doesn't need to have a Blu-ray or HD-DVD drive to watch high-definition content, but we're not quite to that point where everybody is on board with this idea. Disc-based formats, especially for games and movies, is still a very popular and preferred option.

Netflix for the Xbox can be a huge rival to the blu-ray HD exclusiveness of the PS3, but it's going to take some time. The availability of HD content is slim, and only a very small percentage of the current popular titles, are available through the Instant Watch.

Chances are, if you have a PlayStation 3, you probably also have a Netflix subscription to take advantage of their available Blu-ray library. Netflix offers Blu-ray discs as part of its rental service, and more than 85 of the Top 100 movies are available in Blu-ray.

Even though Blu-ray is more expensive, the costs are becoming more reasonable, and it's obvious that the format is gaining popularity. No matter which system you go with for your home theater experience, you are going to have to spend some money.

If you're looking for the best high-definition home theater experience, you're going to need a high-defintion television. The best and easiest HD experience comes with the PlayStation 3.

While Netflix's Instant Watch might make for a pleasant experience for some movies and television series, until it offers more popular titles, in high-definition, the PlayStation 3 and Blu-ray will have the upper hand.

These are reasons why the PlayStation 3 is the best option for your home theater experience.

Next up on the pound-for-pound comparison of the Xbox 360 and PS3 is: which one has the better game library?

Digg!

September 3, 2009

360 vs PS3 - Which Offers a Better Online Experience?

Troy Benedict Says Welcome to the first of a multi-part, pound-for-pound, comparison between Microsoft's Xbox 360 Elite and Sony's PlayStation 3. Now that both systems are available for the same retail price it's an even playing field, right?

Microsoft and Sony both claim that their system is the best deal for that price. They both offer a unique online gaming experience, both can be used to watch movies, both have an exclusive games library, and both have unique hardware benefits. But which one is really better?

During this series I will first look at the simple facts of each category and pass a judgment based only on the facts. I will then take a deeper look at each system's strengths and weaknesses in each category. For example, I will offer a counter-point in some instances or discuss any hidden fees or required accessories that aren't mentioned in the simple facts.

The points I make are all objective, but the final judgment is subjective. Now that the rules have been explained, let's move on.

PlayStation 3 users have boasted that their free-to-play online gaming infrastructure is superior to Xbox 360's. Is it really?

Let's begin the pound-per-pound comparison of the Xbox 360 Elite and the PlayStation 3 with a look at each system's online gaming experience!

SIMPLE FACTS - ONLINE EXPERIENCE:
  • It is absolutely 100% free to play games using a PlayStation 3. A Gold Membership, which retails for $50, is required to play online using an Xbox 360.

  • Every Xbox 360 Elite comes packaged with a headset for online chat. The PlayStation 3 does not come with a headset for voice communication.

  • The PlayStation 3 can be connected to the wireless network without any additional costs. A $100 wireless adapter is required to connect an Xbox 360 to a wireless network.

Judgment: The PlayStation 3 is absolutely free to sign up and play online. Voice chat, while recommended for team-based games, is not required to play online. The wireless network option is purely a matter of preference, but the $100 price tag for the wifi adapter is a major knock against the Xbox 360.

Based on the simple facts, the PlayStation 3 the best way to get online and play with friends.

DEEPER LOOK - ONLINE EXPERIENCE: The PlayStation 3 is a truly free-to-play system. If you have a valid email address, you can set up an account and hop into a game without it costing you a single cent. There are no strings attached, nor any hidden fees required to play a game online.

The Xbox 360, on the other hand, offers two types of membership: Silver and Gold. The Silver membership is free, but the experience is limited. For example, Silver members cannot play online games against other members--except during certain promotional periods. Silver members also have to wait about a week to download exclusive demos and video content, which is first made available to Gold members. Silver members can purchase and download Xbox Live Arcade games and other premium content the same day it's released on Xbox Live Marketplace. A Gold membership requires the purchase of monthly or annual subscriptions. A 13-month subscription retails for $50. However, most frugal shoppers can get a membership for as low as $30. Some retailers will include console bundles that include a gold membership for no additional cost.

The PlayStation 3 might offer a free-to-play online service, but the Xbox 360 offers a much more feature-rich community-based experience. This, of course, is my personal opinion, but I will provide some facts to back up my opinion.The Xbox 360 offers the following online features that the PlayStation 3 (as of firmware 3.0) does not:

  • Cross-game invites - This means that you can send a request to a friend to join your game, even when they're playing a completely different game.

  • Group Chat - On Xbox 360, you and any other gold members can form a party and chat, even if the members of the group are watching different video content or playing different games.

  • Voice Messages - While this option seems almost expected, the PlayStation 3 does not offer the and ability to send a member a voice message. The Xbox 360 does.

  • While both online experiences offer a friends list, the details of what your friends are playing, and how your gaming skills compares to theirs, is much more detailed on the Xbox 360.

  • Achievements and achievement points have been included in every single Xbox 360 game, and are used as something of a digital bragging rights amongst gamers. The Xbox 360 ties the achievement information into each gamer's profile with a Gamerscore--a sum of collected achievement points.

  • Xbox 360 also has better online integration with leaderboards. Even if you're not competing directly with one of your friends in an online game, you can still try to best their scores on a leaderboard.

PlayStation's answer to the community aspect for the PS3 is PlayStation Home. A free community-based service where each user has an custom avatar, a "HomeSpace" to customize with default items, and a world of social environments to explore, like the bowling alley, the mall (where you can purchase items for your HomeSpace or avatar). There are also custom game-themed areas to explore, based around popular titles like Resident Evil 5 and Uncharted.

PlayStation Home has been criticized by gaming media as well as vocal gaming enthusiasts that it didn't and still hasn't delivered to its original potential. For example, friends can get together to play a game of virtual bowling, or play on some of the in-game arcade games, but they still have to wait in line for other virtual players to finish playing their virtual games. Originally, players were told they could decorate their HomeSpaces with trophies achieved by playing certain games, or invite your friends over and watch a movie or other piece of video content on your HomeSpace's television. None of those features have been executed or effectively implemented yet. A major patch, version 1.3, is expected to be released this month and will address a lot of issues including universal game launching from within Home.

The Xbox 360 also has a more effective system with which to file complaints against other users. In fact, Microsoft's Stephen Toulouse, the Director of Policy and Enforcement for Xbox Live, has been spotlighted by gaming media several times, discussing how he and his team review every complaint filed against a user. He also has said that because of the way that Xbox and Xbox Live was developed, it is possible to determine when people are playing with modified Xbox 360 hardware, cheating the achievement system, and illegally obtaining premium content for free. These people can be suspended on several different levels, or have their gamertag and/or console banned from the online service.

Because the PlayStation 3 is a more open service to almost anybody with a valid email address, policing the system is a lot more difficult. Sony has also not been very vocal about discussing the security with their system.

It is a fact that every Xbox 360 Elite comes packaged with a headset. The PlayStation 3 does not come with a headset.

Any Bluetooth headset should pair up with the PlayStation 3, however, the often-recommended Official PlayStation 3 Bluetooth headset retails for $50. Frugal shoppers can find it for cheaper. Any USB headset with a microphone should also work, but the length of the cord will limit the player's distance from the system.

Voice communication is purely a preference, but when its required, Xbox 360 owners should be prepared without any additional cost, and because the headset plugs into the controller, there should never been an unexpected loss of communication -- unless the controller runs out of battery power, too.

Finally, let's discuss the issue of wireless connection options on both systems. Xbox 360 requires the additional purchase of a $100 wireless adapter, while the PlayStation 3 has it built in. This is a huge plus in the PlayStation 3's corner - but it's also a matter of preference, which, to me lessens the advantage.

Personally, I have both the PS3 and 360 plugged into the Internet via Ethernet cables. I have digital cable, and the Internet router is split off from the connection that goes to my cable box. I've never had the cable box or the router more than a few feet from my television and entertainment center. All of the gamers I know personally have their 360s or PS3s connected via Ethernet cables. I can see the PS3's advantage in a home where there are multiple systems spread across several different rooms in the house, and not just connected to the "main television." Like I said, wireless is a personal preference. To me it's not that big of a deal, but perhaps to others, it's a very big issue.

Judgment - Deeper Look
Just because a system is free doesn't always mean that it's better.

Based on the deeper look, I have to say that the Xbox 360 offers a better online experience. It is very obvious that a lot of thought and planning went into developing every part of the experience, both off and online. Sure, you're going to have to pay for an annual subscription, and might have to purchase a wireless adapter depending the layout of your home, but the integration of online gaming, community, and security is so much better on Xbox 360.

Even though free is good, sometimes things are just worth paying for.

The next article in this series looks at which console offers a better movie-watching experience?

Digg!
JimmyJames70